Active Vs Passive- The debate continues

Active vs. Passive – the debate continues.

The active versus passive asset management debate is ongoing, and despite numerous studies, there remain hardcore supporters and detractors of both approaches. In theory, active management has the potential to produce market-beating returns. The main premise for active management is that information asymmetry exists, i.e… There are inefficiencies in the market. It would therefore be possible to identify undervalued securities and buy or sell them at the right time.

The efficient market hypothesis/theory (EMH) states that a share’s price reflects all available information and trades at its fair value. Therefore, it is impossible to generate alpha, and impossible to outperform the market through active management. Your only solution, when the market is fully efficient, is to invest in riskier assets.

So, are markets efficient? Behavioral finance states that people can be negatively affected by behavioral biases. This is in direct conflict with the EMH, where all market participants view stock prices rationally. An example of this is a 2003 study published in the Journal of Finance. The study examined “the relationship between morning sunshine in the city of a country’s leading stock exchange and daily market index returns” in 26 countries between 1982 and 1997. The study concluded that “sunshine is strongly significantly correlated with stock returns.”

Performance

So, if we assume that markets are inefficient, and therefore provide an opportunity for active managers to seek and achieve potential Alpha, let’s delve into the historical performance of active versus passive and see who wins.

In a report produced by Morningstar across a range of stocks, real estate, and bonds on an equal-weighted basis for the 10 years to the end of 2022, active management only outperformed passive in 5 out of 20 categories. This is reflected in the table below:

Further information from the Morningstar report is that 69% of the actively managed funds in the large-growth category that existed 20 years ago are now defunct, and only 5% of these funds managed to both survive and outperform their average passive peer. This does not bode well for active managers. In the fixed-income or bond space, active managers fared slightly better but still, only 43% of active bond managers survived and outperformed their passive counterparts in the past 10 years.

Interestingly, of the active managers analysed in the barometer over the same 10-year period to the end of 2022, the lower-cost funds either matched or outperformed the more expensive funds in every category. This is reflected in the table below:

Conclusion

There is a place for both active and passive management in a portfolio. The more inefficient the market, the greater the potential return. Whilst the majority of active managers have failed, there are those that have succeeded. Doing careful and detailed analysis and choosing your active managers (without allowing behaviour to impact your choice) is critical. Getting this right is not impossible to achieve above-market returns through active management.

Share:

Facebook
Twitter
Pinterest
LinkedIn

Leave a Comment

On Key

Related Posts

The 2026 US Midterms: What the Result Means for Markets

Key takeaways Democrats won both chambers of Congress and governor races in traditionally Republican states, including Texas, setting up divided government from January 2027. History offers a striking pattern: since 1938, the S&P 500 has been positive in roughly 95% of the 12-month periods following a midterm election, according to the historical analysis in the

The 2026 Mini-Budget: What You Need to Know

On 21 October, Finance Minister Enoch Godongwana gave his mini-budget speech in Cape Town, Parliament. In short: South Africa’s finances are in better shape, but the economy is still growing too slowly. Take note: The Medium-Term Budget Policy Statement (MTBPS) is relevant until the February 2027 Main Budget Speech GROWTH The 2026 growth forecast was

Quarter 3 2026- Market Commentary

Global overview The third quarter delivered a reminder that the biggest surprises do not always come from the riskiest assets. For most of July and August, markets enjoyed a steady summer, supported by strong company earnings and continued enthusiasm for artificial intelligence. In September, the bond market took centre stage. The MSCI World Index fell

Understanding the value of your business

Understanding the value of your business Over the years, many clients have asked us: “How do I determine what my company is worth, and who can help me value it?” For a business owner, the answer is often deeply personal. Your company may represent years of hard work, a significant share of your wealth and

The Last Plan You Make for the People You Love

The Last Plan You Make for the People You Love A few months ago, a client told me she thought her affairs were “sorted”. She had a will drawn up when she got married, and had been contributing to a retirement annuity since her twenties. It was only when we sat down together that we

Bronwyn Powrie

Client Administration

Bronwyn joined Parity Wealth Managers in 2026 as a Client Administrator. In her role, she provides dedicated administrative support to clients and her team, helping to ensure a seamless and efficient client experience. She assists with client onboarding, the preparation and processing of documentation, ongoing client servicing, and a range of administrative tasks. Bronwyn also supports foreign exchange transactions and related administration for The FX Desk.

Bronwyn is passionate about learning and continuously developing her skills within the financial services industry. She enjoys being part of a collaborative team that is committed to delivering exceptional client service and looks forward to growing and contributing to the continued success of the business.

Kyle Muller

Wealth Manager

Kyle is a seasoned financial professional, boasting over seven years of expertise in global investment markets and comprehensive structuring. He possesses extensive experience in managing South African exchange control regulations. Specializing in devising strategic solutions, Kyle excels at optimizing investment strategies for individuals and families, while also providing efficient structuring solutions that adeptly navigate complex regulatory landscapes.